Representing the Rights of Injured Individuals Law Offices of Ronald A. Ramos
Law Offices of Ronald A. Ramos

Seventy Three Year Old Amputee Fights Texas Workers’ Compensation Claim Denial

The Texas Tribune filed a detailed report on a very tragic case of an elderly woman who lost her leg in a car accident. The accident occurred when she was commuting home from a work meeting in Houston. Jane Hays, who as an employee worked managing insurance claims, was critically injured when another vehicle crossed the highway and hit her at around seventy miles per hour. Her workers’ compensation claim has been denied due to the fact the the accident occurred when she was travelling home from work and therefore was not considered to be ‘on the job’ at the time of the accident. If you have been injured driving somewhere necessary for work, or injured in relation to your work duties in any way, contact an experienced San Antonio work injury law firm today.

Injured While Commuting to Work: The ‘Course and Scope’ Standard

According to her official denial letter, Jane Hays could not recover workers’ compensation because her injury was not sustained in the ‘course and scope’ of her employment. The course and scope standard dates back to the original Texas Workers’ Compensation law over one hundred years ago. The standard states that anything done by an employee in furtherance of the business affairs of the employer is to be considered within the course and scope of the job. And further, it does not matter whether or not the employee was actually on the employer’s premises at the time of the injury.

Is Commuting Covered by Workers Comp?

Based on the original definition of ‘course and scope’ it sounds like commuting should be covered. In reality under current interpretation of the Texas Labor Code there is a significant grey area. An employee who is travelling for business reasons and who is using transportation that was paid for by the employer is generally considered to be on the job. Jane Hays was being reimbursed for her mileage by her employer and was returning home from an employer mandated business meeting when the accident took place. The dispute over the case is in the early stages, but there is reason to believe that Jane Hays might be able to prevail. If you were injured in a car accident on your way to work, or in relation to your employment, you may be entitled to workers’ compensation.

Contact An Experienced Texas Work Injury Attorney

There are a lot of grey areas in Texas work injury law, an experienced workplace injury attorney is crucial to protect your rights. This case demonstrates that the battle that injured Texas workers are forced to fight is never easy. Workers’ compensation claims are often fought against very hard by the state and insurers. It is important the we protect the rights of every worker, anyone injured on the job must be fully and fairly compensated. If you, or your loved one, is about to file for workers’ compensation or you feel that your claim was unfairly denied, contact and experienced attorney as soon as possible.

Client Reviews
I was in a minor car accident when I first moved to San Antonio. I wasn’t sure if I needed a lawyer but I eventually contacted theLaw Offices of Ronald A. Ramos, P.C. and I’m glad I did. I highly recommend this firm! A.W. - Online Review
Mr. Ramos (Law Offices of Ronald A. Ramos, P.C.) and his staff were GREAT!! I went to their office after a major car accident, and I was not getting anywhere with the insurance company, He and his staff helped me [get] way more than what I was offered by the insurance company its self. N.G. - Online Review
The people at the Law Offices of Ronald A. Ramos, P.C. couldn’t have been any more helpful. Their friendly service team has so much knowledge to offer when it comes to seeking legal advice in a variety of different subjects. They come highly recommended if anyone is looking for any sort of help! M.C. - Online Review
Mr. Ramos has secured a spot as one of the best trial attorneys in San Antonio. His extensive knowledge of the law, ability to connect with jurors, and his admirable reputation among both judges and attorneys make him an absolute asset to the legal community. If you have the opportunity to retain him as legal counsel, consider it a huge privilege. Daniel J. Palmer - Lawyer in San Antonio, TX
Mr. Ramos and his staff are very diligent and effective in litigating personal injury claims and other torts. His representation of clients have resulted in successful outcomes. I myself will refer any cases that will require litigation and a greater expertise. Jesus Vargas - San Antonio, TX Attorney